Malcolm Gladwell is a sports fan.: ESPN.com's Bill Simmons interviews Malcolm Gladwell, the Canadian author of bestsellers Blink and The Tipping Point, and staff writer for The New Yorker magazine. This is the first part of the interview; the second part is due tomorrow.
posted by worldcup2002 to culture at 10:59 PM - 11 comments
Great link, WC. They both write nicely (Gladwell especially) and I really enjoyed some of that Mickelson analysis.
posted by JJ at 05:38 AM on March 03, 2006
The (short) answer is that it's really risky to work hard, because then if you fail you can no longer say that you failed because you didn't work hard. Someone send this link to the Bode Miller camp.
posted by JJ at 06:43 AM on March 03, 2006
Malcolm Gladwell certainly knows how to spin a yarn and stretch it elastic. He writes: "Rural Ontario is not, exactly, a hotbed of athletic ability. I think I read somewhere that Jason Williams (the point guard) and Randy Moss went to the same high school. How is that even possible? If Brian Scalabrine went to my high school, it would now be called the Brian Scalabrine Memorial High School." First of all, what Gladwell calls "rural Ontario," he's not talking about villages north of Lake Superior, he's talking specifically about Elmira, a bedroom suburban hamlet of 15,000 people that looks barely different from anything you might see a couple miles away from college towns like Bloomington, Indiana with some pastureland out the backyard and a 5-10 minute drive to a neraby small city (Kitchener-Waterloo). The high-school Gladwell attended was the same high school attended by Dan Snider, the Atlanta Thrasher killed in an auto accident by Danny Heatley. No change on the school name. And when Gladwell was a high school student, nearby Kitchener-Waterloo schools were stuffed with future professional athletes the same age as him. KCI alone had 8 or 9 future NHLers, including Brian Bellows and Al MacInnis. At that point Bellows was 16 years old and already recipient of a full-page profile in Sports Illustrated. Another student at KCI at the exact same time was world record holder in breastroke swimming and future Olympic gold medallist Victor Davis (wot a nutter!). Those same years, just down the road at Cameron Heights was Lennox Lewis, who was another gold medallist and later became undisputed heavyweight champion, and at Forest Heights was future Stanley Cup captain Scott Stevens, and over at Eastwood was Markus Koch, who won a Superbowl with the 1988 Redskins, playing football. Those schools are all pretty close, and Kitchener-Waterloo is hardly a huge city. At the time Gladwell was in the neighborhood there was probably 250,000 total for the twin-cities and only a small handful of highschools, just a few miles from where Gladwell was raised. The highschool parties, yes even bush parties in St. Jacobs (which is where Darryl Sittler is from) and a rocks throw from Elmira, were regulared by many of these guys, it was common (sorry, I don't name names about what athletes burned their lips doing hotknives) and none of the other metalheads, boozers or teenage-dopers batted an eyelash, it seemed normal. At the exact precise time Gladwell was a student in the neighborhood and laying back on his bed fantasizing about NBA stars on the posters of his walls, there was an amazing cast of athletes in his own backyard he missed, and none of the locals cared that there names weren't Brian Scalabrine.
posted by the red terror at 11:03 AM on March 03, 2006
So I guess his army of fact-checkers let him down on this one, eh? Nice smackdown, red terror. And nice link, wc2k2.
posted by qbert72 at 01:10 PM on March 03, 2006
Also, Malcolm Gladwell looks like Phil Spector and Sideshow Bob.
posted by worldcup2002 at 03:58 PM on March 03, 2006
red terror - great points and analysis. maybe you should have at him on his blog. I mean getting feedback from readers is sort of his raison d'être for it. And he's got a post about the Sports Guy exchange. tho' it is Snyder and Dany if you go that route
posted by gspm at 04:38 PM on March 03, 2006
Hey, I used to work with a guy from Kitchener, Ontario in Darwin, Australia about 20 years ago. Why isn't the high school named after him?
posted by owlhouse at 05:14 AM on March 04, 2006
I was on Stewart Island at the very bottom of NZ about 18 years ago. A local asked me and a friend where we were from. Of course, we knew people in Toronto that didn't even know where Waterloo was, so my friend answered, "Kitchener -- it's near Toronto." The guy stood there thinking for a second, rolling the name over in his head ... "Kitchener .. Kitchener ... say, isn't that near the University of Waterloo?"
posted by the red terror at 10:56 AM on March 04, 2006
ps. things work differently in Canada than they do in the United States. I was riding my bicycle through Northampton, Mass 22 years ago (part of a 2000-mile cycle trip my buddies thought was a good idea at the time) and everything in that town, from the school, to the main drag, to the bridge over the river was named after former president Calvin Coolidge. That seemed peculiar to me, because the high school I attended was the same alma mater as MacKenzie King, and hardly anybody that even attended the school knew it. MacKenzie King is the longest serving Prime Minister in the history of the British Commonwealth, he was PM for 21 years, he worked with Churchill and Roosevelt to wage war against the Nazis, and decades afterward was virtually unknown at his own high school. When history teachers mentioned him in class, they were more inclined to chuckle about how during WW2 he used to channel his deceased mother during seances with his pet dog Pat. Last year, for the school's 150th anniversary, they erected a small statue of King at the school, so hopefully teenagers will get clued in. But if this had been America, like Gladwell says, the school would have been renamed. And history teachers would probably be too scared to talk about occult seances for fear they'll get snitched by outraged Stasi-style students.
posted by the red terror at 12:16 PM on March 04, 2006
Wasn't King hosting the dinner at which Churchill gave the "Some chicken; some neck" speech? That has no bearing on anything - but it is five in the morning and I'm out of my face, so I'm posting it anyway.
posted by JJ at 10:55 PM on March 04, 2006
I'm now to the point where I'm suspicious of people who don't love what they do in the same way. I was watching golf, before Christmas, and the announcer said of Phil Mickelson that the tournament was the first time he'd picked up a golf club in five weeks. Assuming that's true, isn't that profoundly weird? How can you be one of the top two or three golfers of your generation and go five weeks without doing the thing you love? Did Mickelson also not have sex with his wife for five weeks? Did he give up chocolate for five weeks? Is this some weird golfer's version of Lent that I'm unaware of? They say that Wayne Gretzky, as a 2-year-old, would cry when the Saturday night hockey game on TV was over, because it seemed to him at that age unbearably sad that something he loved so much had to come to end, and I've always thought that was the simplest explanation for why Gretzky was Gretzky. And surely it's the explanation as well for why Mickelson will never be Tiger Woods. Brilliant. We need to get him to do an article ;)
posted by justgary at 11:31 PM on March 02, 2006