11/21/24
October 21, 2005
Fire Joe Morgan: Censuring Sports Commentary Since 1931.
posted by jasonspaceman to baseball at 08:58 AM - 25 comments
One thing you can count on with Joe....he knows everything there is to know about baseball and can turn any situation into a "That reminds me of the time when I was playing for the..."
posted by Bury Bonds at 10:18 AM on October 21, 2005
HOW ABOUT THEM ASTROS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! You said already.
posted by lil_brown_bat at 10:51 AM on October 21, 2005
By fire do you mean terminate employment or shoot out of a cannon?
posted by chris2sy at 11:54 AM on October 21, 2005
Oh come on! I think this blog, and the person who wrote it, is more annoying than Joe ever has been...
posted by slackerman at 12:08 PM on October 21, 2005
I think yerfatma has linked to this site a couple times (not as a front page post however).
posted by justgary at 12:16 PM on October 21, 2005
He is a very well knowledged baseball historian and that's great. But why is it that We always have to listen to stories of his past Reds experiences that he can never have back. While it's understood that Joe was a great ballplayer and has all this knowledge of the sport he truly loves, he needs to find more focus on the now. I remember those days with the Big Red Machine as I remember the teams many other announcers have played for in all sports. But listening to someone continuously go through his memories of 30 years ago only brings annoyance to my ears. Joe, We like you, just stick with the game you are calling, and for god sakes...Pep it up a bit too!
posted by melcarek69 at 12:54 PM on October 21, 2005
Joe Morgan is OK. Dump Chris 'the blimp' Berman on ESPN. His overly zealous hoopla belongs in a sports bar ( where he should be ) throwing back some JD shots.
posted by lapinskas at 02:14 PM on October 21, 2005
Joe Morgan calls the game of baseball 'then and now'. I learn a little more about the game each time when you have people like morgan calling a baseball game, anyone should be getting fired is them cheerleaders from Fox Sports Net calling the Angels games.
posted by vtek33 at 02:55 PM on October 21, 2005
FIRE JOE MORGAN? HOW STUPID! NOT ONLY IS HE ONE OF THE GREATEST ALL STARS IN BASEBALL HISTORY, HE IS A FEARLESS COMMENTATOR THAT TELLS IT LIKE IT IS INCLUDING THE STRATEGY, WHILE OTHER COMMENTATORS, LIKE VINCE SCULLY, ARE SOFT SOAPERS WHO STILL HANDLE TV GAMES LIKE RADIO OVER-REPORTING THE PLAY-BY PLAY.
posted by honest at 03:27 PM on October 21, 2005
Common! If you were part of the greatest baseball team ever, you'd be constantly talking about it, too. I'm referring to the 1975-76 BIG RED MACHINE!!! Thats right, baby!
posted by Desert Dog at 03:30 PM on October 21, 2005
JM is an annoying blabbermouth. OK, we get it, he knows baseball. He just knows squat about baseball commentating; he is D-U-L-L with a capital ZZZZzzzzz!! I'm still waiting for the the John Madden of Baseball to arrive; a guy who knows his stuff, and is entertaining at the same time.
posted by frank924 at 03:49 PM on October 21, 2005
I'm still waiting for the the John Madden of Baseball A lot of you may disagree, but I think Lou Pinella at least has the potential. (Then again, a lot of people don't like Madden either.)
posted by cl at 03:58 PM on October 21, 2005
...HE IS A FEARLESS COMMENTATOR THAT TELLS IT LIKE IT IS INCLUDING THE STRATEGY, WHILE OTHER COMMENTATORS, LIKE VINCE SCULLY, ARE SOFT SOAPERS WHO STILL HANDLE TV GAMES LIKE RADIO OVER-REPORTING THE PLAY-BY PLAY... You have got to be joking me. No one questions that Joe was a great player, but his analysis is anything but. As for your sullying of the great Vin Scully. Blasphemy. Utter Blasphemy. I repeat so that you may understand: ITS HARD TO DISPUTE WITH THE LOGIC THAT YOU HAVE DISPLAYED SO PROMINENTLY. BUT NONETHELESS IT APPEARS THAT YOU HAVE LESS BRAINS THAN LOWER CASE LETTERS. DO US ALL A FAVOR AND LAY OFF THE CAPS LOCK.
posted by lilnemo at 04:07 PM on October 21, 2005
LIKE VINCE SCULLY, ARE SOFT SOAPERS WHO STILL HANDLE TV GAMES LIKE RADIO OVER-REPORTING THE PLAY-BY PLAY. You insulted Vince Scully? Why don't you just pee on Ted Williams frozen head, if you want to be disrespectful.
posted by grum@work at 04:13 PM on October 21, 2005
You'd rather listen to Joe Morgan than Vin Scully? Somebody drop you on the soft spot when you were a baby?
posted by The_Black_Hand at 04:52 PM on October 21, 2005
John Madden: the guy who made Superbowl XXXVI and his partner Pat Summerall's last broadcast more memorable with his exhortation that Tom Brady should be taking a knee and waiting for overtime with 1:30 remaining on the clock.
posted by the red terror at 05:07 PM on October 21, 2005
Someone dig up the previous thread (I think dusted posted it) about the guy who tried to interview Joe Morgan. Morgan is a paranoid old fool. I learned a lot about NL baseball from him when I was a kid, but his opinions now are nothing short of embarassing. No one defending him has ever listened closely to what he says. Next time he's doing a game, play a little game of your own and think about everything he says as if it were literally true. You'll be amazed. He's impossible. I once saw Karl Ravetch lose his patience on air with Morgan because Joe would not answer the one question he was on air to answer.
posted by yerfatma at 05:49 PM on October 21, 2005
yerfatma, are you thinking of this thread?
posted by lilnemo at 07:19 PM on October 21, 2005
Joe Morgan consistantly passes on false information about the fundamentals of the game. He is wrong about 50 % of the time and speculates (wildly) the other 50%. The average fan knows no better. He was a great player and I loved to watch him. Now... I turn the sound down to avoid being irritated. You average fans out there need to get a clue.
posted by nomoniceguy at 09:10 PM on October 21, 2005
It's actually a crime he has not been hire as a manager. He knows baseball and he knows the players and teams. I've wondered for years now why he has not been offered a job. He is also a baseball celebrity himself which IN itself could be a draw.
posted by mikemora at 10:37 PM on October 21, 2005
Joe Morgan was a great baseball player. He is knowledgeable about the game. But he is also a lousy sportscaster. He is arrogant and dull. Maybe he should be managing or coaching, but sportscasting is not his strong point. Move on Joe.
posted by needle park at 04:17 AM on October 22, 2005
they must mean fire out of a cannon this guy is way to good of an announcer to get rid of maybe gentle george (steinbrenner ) will get him and get rid of john sterling
posted by FrankySP at 08:54 AM on October 22, 2005
i have an idea why not replace him with john sterlimg's understudy suzzy waldmen kill two birds with one stone and get that fountain of baseball literacy and knowledge at the same time
posted by FrankySP at 09:14 AM on October 22, 2005
I've wondered for years now why he has not been offered a job [as a manager]. Because you need to know what you're doing, be able to accept criticism and accept input from others. Apparently people within baseball do not believe Joe is capable of this.
posted by yerfatma at 02:14 PM on October 22, 2005
Why would you fire Joe Morgan? It is refreshing to hear comentary from some one that knows baseball like Joe and several other of the good baseball people who are now commenting on air. HOW ABOUT THEM ASTROS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!